The Super League Young Player of the Year Award: A Launchpad to Greatness or a Fleeting Moment of Glory?
Winning the Super League Young Player of the Year award is often seen as a golden ticket to a successful rugby league career. But what happens after the trophy is lifted? Do these young stars continue to shine, or do they fade into obscurity? Let’s take a deep dive into the journeys of every winner since 2010, exploring their triumphs, setbacks, and where they are now. And this is the part most people miss... some of these stories might surprise you!
2025: Harry Robertson – The Rising Star
St Helens’ Harry Robertson burst onto the scene in 2025, claiming the award after a stellar year at centre. With 12 tries and five assists, he outshone competitors like Junior Nsemba, George Flanagan Jr, and Lewis Martin. If he keeps up this momentum, an international call-up for the World Cup could be on the horizon. But here’s where it gets controversial: Is Robertson truly ready for the global stage, or is the hype getting ahead of reality?
2024: Junior Nsemba – The Almost Repeat Winner
Nsemba’s 2024 victory was followed by another nomination in 2025, though he fell short. His England debut against Samoa marked a significant milestone, but questions remain: Can he regain the form that made him a standout in 2024?
2023: Josh Thewlis – The Reliable Winger
Warrington’s Josh Thewlis has become a first-team staple, stepping up in Matty Ashton’s absence. His opening try in the 2023 Challenge Cup Final showcased his talent, but the Wolves’ defeat left him hungry for more. Is Thewlis the next big thing in Warrington’s backline, or will he remain a solid contributor without reaching superstar status?
2021 & 2022: Jack Welsby – The Back-to-Back Champion
St Helens’ Jack Welsby is one of only two players to win the award consecutively. An England regular, he’s a Grand Final hero and a fan favorite. However, does his recent drop from the Ashes squad signal a decline, or is it just a minor setback?
2020: Harry Newman – The Injury-Plagued Talent
Harry Newman’s 2020 win was overshadowed by a double leg break at Hull KR. Now with the Perth Bears, his potential remains untapped. Can he overcome his injury woes and fulfill his early promise?
2019: Matty Lees – The Saints Stalwart
Matty Lees is celebrating a testimonial year in 2026, nearing 200 appearances for St Helens. His consistency is admirable, but is he destined to be a club legend, or will he seek new challenges elsewhere?
2018: Jake Trueman – The Journeyman
Since winning the award at Castleford, Trueman has moved to Hull FC and now Wakefield. His 18 appearances under Daryl Powell show promise, but has frequent moving hindered his development?
2017: Oliver Gildart – The NRL Returnee
Oliver Gildart’s award-winning year at Wigan saw him score 14 tries in 20 matches. After a stint in the NRL, he’s back in Super League with Hull KR, forming a lethal partnership with Joe Burgess. Can he recapture his Wigan form, or will the NRL experience define his legacy?
2016: Tom Johnstone – The Comeback Kid
Tom Johnstone’s 20 tries in 2016 were followed by injury struggles. His 2025 Ashes call-up after returning to Wakefield suggests a resurgence. Is this a new beginning, or will injuries continue to plague his career?
2015: George Williams – The Global Traveler
George Williams has amassed 338 senior appearances, two World Cups, and 23 England caps. His NRL stint with Canberra Raiders and potential move to the Dolphins in 2027 highlight his versatility. Is he the ultimate utility player, or does his frequent moving lack focus?
2014: Daryl Clark – The Double Winner
Daryl Clark’s 2014 was unforgettable, winning both Young Player of the Year and Man of Steel. Now at St Helens, he’s a Super League and international regular. Can he maintain his dominance, or is he peaking too early?
2013: Ben Crooks – The Championship Switch
Ben Crooks, now at Halifax, has transitioned from centre to the back row. His 20 tries in 2013 for Hull FC seem a distant memory. Is this a career rejuvenation, or a sign of decline?
2012: Zak Hardaker – The Comeback Story
Zak Hardaker’s 2012 Grand Final win with Leeds was followed by a Man of Steel award in 2015. Despite off-field issues, he’s back to his best at Hull FC. Has he truly turned a corner, or will past mistakes haunt him?
2011: Jonny Lomax – The One-Club Man
Jonny Lomax has spent his entire career at St Helens, with 378 appearances and multiple trophies. Is his loyalty admirable, or has he missed out on bigger opportunities?
2010: Sam Tomkins – The Legend
Sam Tomkins, the first back-to-back winner, retired after a stellar career with Wigan and Catalans. His Man of Steel award and Grand Final appearances cement his legacy. Is he the greatest Young Player of the Year winner ever?
Thought-Provoking Question: Which of these players do you think has had the most impactful career post-award, and why? Share your thoughts in the comments—let’s spark a debate!
